top of page

Why Augustine Was Right About Us but Wrong About Eden

1 hour ago
5 min read

Religion and Philosophy


Photo:Wix


Why do we so often fail to do what we know is right? Sixteen centuries ago, Augustine of Hippo found his answer in the story of the Fall. I want to argue that his account of human nature is deeply insightful, because it fits our everyday experience so well. But Augustine was wrong to treat the Fall as a real event in history, because this cannot be squared with what modern science has discovered.


Augustine believed that before the Fall, humans lived in perfect harmony with God, with each other and with nature. The will was driven only by caritas, love directed towards God, and it worked with reason, so desires always stayed under rational control. Then Satan tempted Adam and Eve to eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, and that harmony was destroyed. Sin entered the world, and the will became “divided”, driven instead by cupiditas, or selfish love. At the root of this, Augustine believed, was pride. Just as obedience is the “mother of all virtues”, pride is the root of every vice. This account is convincing because it matches how we actually live. St Paul admits, “I do not do the good I want.” He knows what is good, yet finds himself unable to do it. Most of us know the feeling. We want to get fit or do well in an exam, and still we skip the gym or put off revising. We know what is good for us and choose something else anyway. This is exactly the inner conflict Augustine describes, and it is why his teaching on human nature after the Fall is so insightful.


Some critics argue that the idea of a perfect world going wrong does not make sense, and that this undermines Augustine’s whole account. Schleiermacher argues that a will ruled entirely by caritas would have no reason to become proud. If Adam and Eve were created perfect, how could they choose to sin? Either they had a flaw, which would make God responsible, or sin came from nowhere, which explains nothing. The feminist theologian Valerie Saiving raises a different problem. She argues that Augustine’s focus on pride describes a typically male sin. For many women, she suggests, sin looks more like losing oneself than putting oneself first. If these critics are right, Augustine’s account is not only incoherent but also incomplete, and far less universal than he claims.


However, neither objection succeeds. Augustine does say that pride caused Adam and Eve’s disobedience, but he never claims that anything caused the pride itself. Pride was the first sin, the will freely turning away from God. In City of God, Augustine argues that the evil will has no efficient cause, only a deficient one. Nothing actively produced it. The will simply failed to hold on to God. This fits his view that evil is privatio boni, a lack of good rather than a thing that can be created. Herbert McCabe illustrates this with a hole in a sock. The hole is real, but it is not a thing in itself. Evil is the same, an absence of good rather than something God made. In fact, if something had caused Adam and Eve’s pride, their choice would not have been free and they could not be blamed for it. As Augustine explains, they were able not to sin (posse non peccare) but not yet unable to sin (non posse peccare), so being created good did not make them incapable of choosing wrongly. Saiving’s criticism can also be answered. For Augustine, sin is disordered love, and there is more than one way to love wrongly. Putting yourself first is one way, but losing yourself in others or neglecting yourself is another, since both put something other than God at the centre of your life. Saiving therefore improves Augustine’s teaching rather than proving it wrong. His interpretation of the Fall holds together and still fits human experience.


Despite this insight, Augustine was wrong to read the Fall as history, as he does in The Literal Meaning of Genesis. Evolutionary science and the fossil record show that humans appeared very late in Earth’s long history, and that death, disease and suffering existed for millions of years before them. Scientists have found signs of cancer in a hominin foot bone around 1.7 million years old, long before any first sin could have happened. Natural disasters, such as the asteroid that wiped out the dinosaurs, also took place long before humans existed. If so, Augustine’s historical account cannot be true, because the world was never a perfect place without suffering that Adam and Eve’s sin then spoiled.


Augustine’s defenders argue that his account can be reconciled with evolution. In City of God, Augustine explains that the Fall brought a “double death”, in which humans became mortal in body and separated from God in soul. This means the Fall is mainly about human death and our relationship with God, not about the whole natural world. Augustine also argues that the death of plants and animals is part of the natural order and adds to the beauty of creation, so it is not evil at all. For the rest of natural evil, he points to the fall of the angels, which happened before humans were created. C.S. Lewis, in The Problem of Pain, suggests a way to combine this with science. Humans evolved over a long time, and then God gave the first humans a new kind of consciousness so that they could know and love him. They lived in a perfect relationship with God until they turned away, and only then did human death and suffering begin. On this view, science does not automatically disprove a historical Fall.


But this reply fails. First, it is hard to believe that all animal suffering adds to the beauty of creation. A lion quickly killing a gazelle may seem part of a natural order, but slow and pointless suffering is a different matter. William Rowe asks us to imagine a fawn trapped in a forest fire caused by lightning, burning in agony for several days before it dies, with no human ever knowing. There is nothing beautiful in that. Second, even if animal death is not evil, early humans still suffered disease and death, which Augustine says should not have existed before the Fall. Genetic evidence also shows that the human population never fell to just two people, so there was never a single first couple from whom all humans descend, as Augustine believed. Lewis tries to avoid these problems by saying the first ensouled humans were different from their ancestors, but there is no evidence for this, nor any evidence that early humans were ever free from death and disease while the creatures around them were not. Lewis himself admitted his account was only a “not unlikely tale”, which shows it is speculation rather than evidence. Likewise, there is no evidence that fallen angels cause earthquakes or disease, so this explanation looks like it was added only to protect the theory. Augustine was therefore wrong to teach a historical Fall.


Augustine’s interpretation of the Fall gives a powerful and insightful account of human nature. But he was wrong to treat the Fall as a historical event, because modern science tells a very different story about where suffering and death came from. In fairness to Augustine, he did not have access to these discoveries. And his insight into the divided will does not depend on a historical Eden. It can survive as a symbolic description of the human condition, even though his literal reading cannot.

 
 
 

Comments


©2024 by The No Knuckles Journal.

bottom of page